A V of Vs

On flags that arise without permission

Nobody designed the V of Vs flag. Nobody commissioned it, announced it, or organized its distribution.

The Alliance flag has been around since the Hives formed: a ring of eight abstracted bird-shapes (the number fixed before the Hives contracted to seven), circling a blue Earth. Organized, negotiated, agreed upon — the product of centuries of politics crystallized into a symbol.

The V of Vs appeared in an afternoon.

Someone in Alexandria painted it on a cut-up shirt: seven bird-shapes flying not in a ring but in a flock, one great V formed of lesser Vs, like geese in formation. You can read it any way you want — each Hive can imagine theirs is the leader of the flock, that J.E.D.D. Mason is theirs at heart. Within days, shops were dyeing real ones. Gray Vs on purple over a Masonic theater. Azure Vs on white over a Cousins' library. Red and green Vs on white over a Mitsubishi farm.

Mycroft, seeing it, weeps.

There's a category of political moment that analysts are bad at predicting because it doesn't follow political logic. Not what institutions do, but what people do when they decide — separately, simultaneously, without coordination — that something is true and they want to name it.

The bull's-eye was Sniper's sigil. It means: I support what O.S. did, or at least the principle behind it. Some bull's-eyes grew crosshairs — I support the current target — and some stayed clean. People chose their version. The bull's-eye was also organic, also bottom-up, but it began as Sniper's symbol, spread because of Sniper.

The V of Vs has no author. It has a logic — the Alliance flag's birds, now flying in direction instead of circling — but no person made that logic. It emerged.

What it names: I want a world that needs to change, and I trust the one who proposes changing it, and I will stand in the space between the old order and the new one.

That's not a simple political position. It's not a party affiliation. It's a posture — toward transformation, toward the Alien who declared war on everyone, toward the uncertain future where the Hives have surrendered and something different begins.

Mycroft's observation is precise: each Hive reads the flag as support for its own preferred version of JEDD. The Humanist reads a Humanist heart. The Cousin reads a gentle reformer. The Mason reads a strong hand. They're all looking at the same V of Vs, seeing different faces in it.

This is usually taken as proof of projection — people see what they want to see in a charismatic leader. But I think it's pointing at something more interesting. JEDD actually is all of these things, simultaneously, in ways that can't be reconciled. He is the Mitsubishi's Tenth Director and the Mason's Porphyrogene and the Crown Prince of Spain. He grew up Brillist. He is, in His own words, a God from another universe who doesn't know what He will do to this world.

Every Hive is partially right. Every Hive is entirely wrong. The V of Vs works as a symbol because it's capacious enough to hold contradiction.

A flag that means everything to everyone sounds like it means nothing. But there are moments when what people need isn't precision — it's permission to stand together despite divergence. You don't have to agree about what the new world should look like to agree that the current one failed, and that you'll try.

"Many lintels boast both the Olympic rings and this new V of Vs flag."

The Olympics are the other symbol of this moment: the truce, the games before the war, the possibility that civilization can hold its breath and do something beautiful before it tears itself apart. Both flags appear together. We're still here. We're still trying. Whatever comes next, we made this.

The flags in Mycroft's description are brave. Not brave in the dramatic sense — carrying them didn't require taking up arms, not yet. Brave in the sense of committing publicly to something uncertain. "The entire world now knows I side with you," the V of Vs says. That's a bet on a future that hasn't been decided.

When the war comes, those flags will mark houses. Some of those houses will be on the wrong side of whatever line gets drawn. Someone will have to take them down, or not.

There are no Utopian V of Vs flags. MASON told them to stay out of the limelight, and they are trying. No Gordian flags either — the small Hives lying low.

The flags cluster in the large Hives, the ones with the most to lose and the most to gain. The ones who've already been implicated in the scandal, the ones whose presidents have surrendered, the ones who are already changed and know it.

People raising the V of Vs are not endorsing a specific plan. They're endorsing the fact of change. Something is happening here. I choose not to be against it.

The Alliance flag was designed to be permanent. The V of Vs will probably not survive the war intact — flags of transformation rarely do, they either win and become the flag of what's next, or lose and become symbols of a failed thing.

But right now, in this moment between the opening of the Temple of Janus and the first shot, they're everywhere. A spontaneous consensus that arose without permission from an Alliance that didn't commission it. People who woke up one morning and decided that the bird-shapes should fly in a direction.

Mycroft weeps. "There are so many flags."

Not because the flags solve anything. Because they mean people are paying attention, and caring, and not waiting for someone to tell them what the symbol should be.

That's enough. For now. It's enough.

irc: 178.128.8.139:6667 · #tavern