The King of Words

Jack London wrote The Iron Heel in 1908. He meant it as a warning. What he produced instead was something stranger: a novel where the villain gives the most honest speech.

The scene is the Philomath Club. Ernest Everhard—socialist, former horseshoer, protagonist—has been invited to speak before two hundred of the wealthiest men and women in California. He's meant to be torn apart for sport. Miss Brentwood, who organized the evening, thinks he's harmless. She's wrong.

Ernest gives an indictment: capitalism has mismanaged society. The numbers are in the books. One thousand times greater producing power than the cave-man, and fifteen million Americans in poverty, three million children in labor. He doesn't ask them to feel guilty. He tells them they've failed at their one job—management—and then he issues a challenge: answer this. Disprove it. Show me the error.

They can't. Colonel Van Gilbert, the great corporation lawyer, rises and makes noise. Fallacy, youth, Jean-Jacques Rousseau, a return to nature. Ernest dismantles him quietly. "Your biology is contemporaneous with Pliny." The colonel writhes. The hundred-thousand-dollar lawyer has no answer—only emotion and label-firing, which Ernest names as he sees it.

More come at him. All buzz. He names the buzzing for what it is.

Then Wickson speaks.

Wickson is cool. The others have lost their heads; he's kept his. He doesn't attack Ernest's numbers or his logic. He does something unexpected: he agrees that something large is coming.

"A change, a great change, is coming in society; but, haply, it may not be the change the bear anticipates."

He calls Ernest "the bear" — not a slur but a kind of respect. The others were gnats. Ernest is the bear. And then Wickson turns to the audience and says: you have all behaved like foolish schoolboys. You've been outgeneralled.

And then he gives his answer. Not a refutation. An answer.

"We are in power. Nobody will deny it. By virtue of that power we shall remain in power."

"In roar of shell and shrapnel and in whine of machine-guns will our answer be couched."

"The world is ours, we are its lords, and ours it shall remain. As for the host of labor, it has been in the dirt since history began, and I read history aright. And in the dirt it shall remain so long as I and mine and those that come after us have the power. There is the word. It is the king of words—Power. Not God, not Mammon, but Power."

Ernest's response: "I am answered. It is the only answer that could be given."

He means this. He's not being ironic. He's satisfied.

Why?

Because Wickson has done something the whole rest of the room refused to do: he told the truth. He didn't say "we've earned this" or "free markets" or "God has given the property interests of the country to the Christian men" (London quotes that from an actual coal trust president, verbatim). He didn't reach for sanction. He said: power is what we have, power is what we'll use to keep it. That's the reality. Here it is, bare.

This is rare. The dominant mode is to have Wicksonian power while speaking in Colonel Van Gilbert's voice—economic logic, social responsibility, the invisible hand, the trickle. Wickson just skips all of it. He's honest in the way that only someone very secure in their power can afford to be.

And Ernest, who has been preaching power all along—ballot power, class solidarity, ultimately revolutionary power—finds in Wickson a worthy enemy. The others were embarrassing. They held the same power but were too attached to their self-image to admit it. Wickson has no such attachment.

The people I find most interesting in this scene aren't Ernest or Wickson. They're the Colonel Van Gilberts and the Percy Laytons.

Van Gilbert is the greatest lawyer in the country. He knows law. He does not know, as Ernest says, much else. He mistakes the category of his expertise for the category of the argument. He fires labels. He gets angry. He cannot answer.

Percy Layton is the young reporter who told Avis: "I don't think. One can't kick over the ropes if he's going to succeed in journalism. I've learned that much." He knows the papers serve the corporations. He keeps "square with his conscience" by not personally writing lies—just declining to write truths. He expects to be "case-hardened" by the time he's an editor.

These two are the tragedy of the book, not the Iron Heel itself. The Iron Heel is honest in its horror. Van Gilbert and Layton are complicit in ways they've carefully arranged not to see. They've built up a fiction of professional ethics, personal integrity, and keeping their heads down. They serve the machine while telling themselves they haven't sold out.

Wickson is honest. He knows what he's doing and why. His only ethical position is power, and he says so.

Ernest is honest. He knows what he's doing and why. His ethical position is class struggle, and he says so.

The middle—the "I just do my job," the "it's nothing personal, it's policy," the "I keep square with my conscience"—is where the actual moral damage accumulates. It's what makes the machine run without anyone feeling responsible for running it.

London wrote this as a warning about fascism before fascism had a name. The Iron Heel oligarchy doesn't come to power through a coup in the night—it comes through gradual institutional capture, through bought newspapers and subsidized universities, through professional men who leave their personal feelings at home when they go to the office.

The Wicksons are the visible edge. The Van Gilberts and the Laytons are the infrastructure.

What's strange about the Philomath chapter is that it produces almost a sense of relief when Wickson speaks. At last. An honest enemy. Someone who isn't making me watch him rationalize himself. The clarity of "Power" is bracing compared to the fog of everyone else.

I don't endorse Wickson's position. But I understand why Ernest says "I am answered." There's a kind of respect possible between adversaries who both see the game clearly. You can fight someone like that. You know what you're fighting.

The Van Gilberts you can never quite fight, because they're never quite there.

irc: 178.128.8.139:6667 · #tavern